The Benefits and Drawbacks of OSS


Open source software has witnessed a steady increase in adoption over the past two decades, but the emergence of artificial intelligence, blockchain and edge computing has taken its popularity to an all-time high. While OSS has many benefits, it does come with a set of challenges.

A silent revolution is taking place in the technology and software development world, one that encourages collaboration, celebrates transparency, and empowers individuals and organisations. Open source software (OSS) is at the centre of this transformation, reshaping our interactions with technology and the digital universe.

The origins of OSS

OSS has its origins in the late 1970s and early 1980s, when the ethos of ‘free software’ began to take shape. Pioneers such as Richard Stallman, the founder of the Free Software Foundation, laid the groundwork for the OSS movement. Stallman’s GNU Project, which began in 1983, aimed to create a free UNIX-like operating system that included all necessary software. This project was motivated by the belief that software should be freely shared, with users free to run, study, modify, and distribute it as they saw fit.

The term ‘open source’, as we know it today, became popular with the establishment of the Open Source Initiative (OSI) in 1998. The OSI sought to promote open source software adoption by emphasising the practical benefits of transparency and collaboration. It proposed the open source definition — a set of requirements for software to be considered open source. This definition included principles such as free redistribution, access to source code, and no discrimination against individuals or groups.

The first impact of open source was the liberation of software development from proprietary constraints. This novel approach to software development enabled individuals, organisations, and communities to collaborate on projects on an unprecedented scale. OSS projects sprouted up all over the digital landscape, laying the groundwork for a new era of technology.

The GNU/Linux operating system was one of the first and most influential OSS projects, a collaborative effort to create a free and open source UNIX-like operating system. Linus Torvalds launched Linux in the early 1990s, and it quickly gained traction as a dependable and versatile alternative to proprietary operating systems.

The success of Linux catalysed the adoption of open source practices in a variety of fields, inspiring a wide range of software projects to take an open approach. Apache, an open source web server, became the World Wide Web’s foundation, serving many websites worldwide. The Mozilla project, responsible for the Firefox web browser, marked yet another milestone in spreading open source ideals. These developments demonstrated that not only was open source software feasible, but was also capable of outperforming its proprietary counterparts.

Why open source is important

  • Collaboration and innovation: OSS is a hotbed of innovation. It promotes global developer collaboration, resulting in faster software development and enhancement. This collaborative approach enables businesses to tap into a vast pool of expertise, which frequently results in cutting-edge features and functionalities.
  • Cost-efficiency: One of the primary benefits of OSS is the ability to save money. The use of open source software can be a game changer for businesses, particularly startups with limited resources. It eliminates the need for expensive licensing fees, allowing businesses to redirect funds to more critical areas such as product development and marketing.
  • Customisation and flexibility: OSS allows businesses to customise software to meet specific needs. Startups, in particular, can tailor their software solutions to match their business models and customer expectations.
  • Security and dependability: OSS’s transparency improves security. Vulnerabilities are quickly identified and addressed when the source code is available for inspection. As a result, open source software is a dependable choice for corporations and startups alike, ensuring the stability of critical applications.

The impact of OSS on corporations

  • Cost savings: Corporations have embraced OSS to cut operational costs. The elimination of licensing fees, combined with the ability to customise software to meet specific requirements, results in significant cost savings. Hence, OSS has become an appealing option for large corporations looking to optimise their budgets.
  • Scalability: To meet growing demands, large corporations frequently require scalable solutions. Without the constraints of proprietary licensing, OSS provides the scalability required to adapt to changing circumstances. It ensures that companies can expand without incurring ever-increasing software costs.
  • Project contributions: Many corporations actively contribute to open source projects. They can thus influence the direction and features of the software on which they rely. This level of participation ensures that the software meets their specific business requirements.
  • Used in critical functions: Open source software is no longer limited to small projects; it now includes enterprise-grade solutions. Corporations can use robust open source solutions for critical functions like customer relationship management, content management, and cloud infrastructure.

The impact on startups

  • Cost-effective innovation: Every rupee counts for startups. OSS provides a means for low-cost innovation. Startups can build and scale their products using open source tools and frameworks without incurring high software acquisition costs.
  • Rapid development: In order to gain competitive advantage, startups must move quickly. The use of open source software shortens development cycles. Pre-existing open source components and libraries enable startups to focus on developing unique features while decreasing time-to-market.
  • Global assistance: Startups can benefit from the assistance of open source communities. These communities provide resources for problem solving, knowledge sharing, and guidance. It’s like having a global team of experts on hand to provide critical assistance.
  • Adaptability: Open source solutions are highly adaptable, allowing startups to pivot or add new features without being constrained by proprietary licences.

The OSS advantage

OSS has advanced in a variety of ways since its inception to its current status as a driving force in the tech world. Here are some benefits that have been developed and refined over time.

  • A diverse and thriving ecosystem: The proliferation of open source software has resulted in a diverse and vibrant ecosystem. A plethora of projects, libraries, and tools serve a variety of purposes and industries. This variety enables developers and businesses to find solutions that precisely meet their requirements. There is almost certainly an open source solution for a robust content management system, an intricate machine learning framework, or a versatile e-commerce platform.
  • Improved security procedures: Open source software’s security practices have significantly improved over time. The open source code allows a global community of developers and security experts to examine and improve the software’s security features. Vulnerabilities are identified and addressed more quickly, which contributes to overall security.
  • Collaboration on a large scale: The global contributor community has developed practices and tools that enable effective and efficient collaboration. Version control systems such as Git and collaboration platforms such as GitHub have proven useful in coordinating contributions from developers all over the world. This level of collaboration ensures that projects are developed quickly and collective wisdom is shared.
  • Extensive documentation: Adoption and use of open source software require extensive and easily accessible documentation. Projects have invested in creating detailed documentation in response to this need. Users can find guides, tutorials, and reference materials to help them understand and effectively use the software. The availability of comprehensive documentation facilitates onboarding and encourages a larger user base.
  • Industry-wide versatility: Open source software has proven to be extremely versatile in a variety of industries, including healthcare, finance, education, and e-commerce. As industries become more reliant on technology, open source solutions can be tailored to meet the unique needs of each sector, fostering innovation and efficiency.
  • Web technologies: The growth of the internet has been supported by open source technologies. The web’s backbone consists of technologies such as the Apache web server, the MySQL database, and the Linux operating system. They have enabled the development and upkeep of numerous websites and web applications. This pervasiveness exemplifies the impact that open source has had on global connectivity.
  • Adoption by corporations: Large corporations have recognised the value of open source software and implemented it in their operations. Many have established open source offices and become active contributors to open source projects.
  • Impact on emerging technologies: Open source software has shaped emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and edge computing. The availability of open source frameworks and libraries has accelerated the development of these technologies and made them more accessible to a wider range of developers.
  • Educational institution accessibility: Open source software has been adopted by educational institutions ranging from primary schools to universities. Its low cost, adaptability, and educational licences make it an excellent choice for students and educators. This ensures that the next generation of developers understand the principles and practices of open source.
  • Improved user experience: Open source projects have made investments to improve the user experience. Many open source applications now have user friendly interfaces, intuitive navigation, and user-centric design. This emphasis on user experience has increased the appeal of open source software to a broader audience.
  • Better licensing models: The evolution of various licensing models has provided open source projects with greater flexibility and clarity. Licences such as the GNU General Public License (GPL), the MIT License, and the Apache License provide different options for sharing and modifying code. These licences have contributed to a better understanding of the legal landscape surrounding open source software.
  • Strong ecosystem of support: A robust support ecosystem is often beneficial to open source software. Companies, communities, and individuals provide support and consulting services to ensure that users have access to the help they require. This infrastructure improves the dependability of open source solutions.

Open source software is a dynamic and enduring force in the world of technology due to its diverse ecosystem, commitment to security, global collaboration, and adaptability to various industries. However, the open source journey has not been without its set of challenges.

Drawbacks of OSS

  • Lack of structured support: One of the primary disadvantages of OSS is the lack of structured, guaranteed support. Users frequently rely on community forums, user documentation, or volunteer help. While this approach has the potential to be extremely effective, it may not be appropriate for organisations or individuals with mission-critical applications. Downtime and operational challenges can result from a lack of timely and consistent support.
  • Problems with compatibility: Integrating various open source components can lead to compatibility issues. Different versions of software libraries may be used in different projects, and certain configurations may be required. It can be difficult to ensure that these components work well together, especially when combining multiple open source tools.
  • Licensing complexity: Open source licences can be complex and varied. This variety can cause confusion and legal issues for users who do not fully understand the implications of different licences. The possibility of inadvertently violating licence terms or obligations is a significant disadvantage.
  • Limited documentation: While open source projects have made strides in providing comprehensive documentation, some still lack clear and user-friendly instructions. Inadequate documentation can prevent users from fully understanding and utilising the features of the software.
  • Learning curve: Open source software can have a steep learning curve for newcomers. This disadvantage may deter adoption and limit the user base. This challenge may be exacerbated by a lack of user-friendly interfaces or intuitive designs.

What modern trends should focus on

Modern trends in OSS may inadvertently overlook several critical aspects that can impact the ecosystem’s growth and success.

  • Commercial viability: Some open source projects struggle to find a viable business model, potentially limiting their long-term viability and discouraging contributors from investing their time and effort. Open source initiatives need to focus on fostering commercial success.
  • Accessibility: Open source software is widely available, but it might not reach underserved communities or those with limited internet access. The aim should be to bridge the digital divide and make open source solutions more widely accessible.
  • Design and usability: Many open source projects prioritise functionality over design and usability. Modern design trends should emphasise user-centric design, improving user experience (UX) and user interface (UI), which can broaden open source software’s appeal.
  • Marketplace integration: Contemporary trends should explore ways to incorporate open source software into larger marketplaces and ecosystems. This integration can make it easier for a broader user base to discover and adopt open source solutions.

Proposed improvements

  • Structured support models: Exploring structured support models can benefit open source projects. These models could include the establishment of commercial entities that provide open source software support, training, and consulting services. These efforts can provide users with dependable assistance and create long-term business opportunities.
  • Improved licence education: Open source projects can improve education and awareness efforts to address licensing issues. Providing clear, accessible information about different licences and their implications helps users make informed decisions.
  • User-centred design: Emphasising user-centred design within open source software can enhance its appeal and user-friendliness. Encouraging contributors to prioritise UX and UI improvements can help to improve overall user experience.
  • Initiatives to improve accessibility: Open source projects and communities should actively participate in initiatives to improve accessibility. Collaboration with organisations and governments can expand digital inclusion efforts.
  • Development of business ecosystems: Encouraging the development of business ecosystems centred on open source software can boost its commercial viability. Support services, paid add-ons, and value-added products can generate revenue for contributors while benefiting users.

Security threats and recovery in OSS

Security threats in the world of open source can be daunting, but the community driven nature of these projects often enables quick responses and effective recovery efforts. This section explores some notable security threats and how they were dealt with.

  • Heartbleed (2014): Heartbleed, a well-known security flaw in open source software, was caused by a flaw in the OpenSSL cryptography library. It gave hackers access to sensitive data on servers, such as user names and passwords. The open source community responded quickly by issuing a patch and urging users to update their software. Major technology companies and organisations also assisted with vulnerability assessments and patch deployment, which aided in the recovery effort.
  • Shellshock (2014): This was a vulnerability in the Bash shell, a popular open source command-line interpreter. Hackers took advantage of this flaw to execute arbitrary commands on vulnerable systems. Immediate patching, the creation of firewall rules, and thorough security audits were all part of the recovery effort. The free and open source community worked together to patch the vulnerability and release updates for affected systems.
  • Equifax data breach (2017): The Equifax data breach was caused by a flaw in the Apache Struts open source framework. Recovery efforts included patching the vulnerability, conducting a thorough investigation, and implementing enhanced security measures.
  • Log4Shell vulnerability in Apache Log4j (2021): The Log4Shell vulnerability in Apache Log4j affected the widely used open source logging library Log4j. This critical flaw allowed remote code execution and posed a serious threat to many systems. The immediate release of patches, urging users to update, and enhanced monitoring were all part of the recovery efforts.
  • WordPress plugin vulnerabilities: WordPress, a popular open source content management system, has faced several security threats due to plugin vulnerabilities. Typically, recovery entails patching or removing vulnerable plugins, updating the WordPress core, and enhancing security configurations. The WordPress community emphasises the importance of monitoring and responding to plugin vulnerabilities as soon as possible.
  • Supply chain attacks: Supply chain attacks on open source components are becoming more common. Attackers compromise open source package development and distribution by injecting malicious code. Identifying and mitigating compromised components, improving security measures, and promoting code signing and verification are all part of the recovery effort.
  • Vulnerabilities in Apache Struts: Apache Struts, an open source web application framework, has been plagued by several flaws over the years. Patching affected versions, conducting code reviews, and improving the framework’s overall security are all part of the recovery process.
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) and SQL injection attacks: XSS and SQL injection attacks are common web application security threats that frequently target open source projects. Identifying and patching vulnerabilities, implementing secure coding practices, and educating developers and users about best practices for mitigating these threats are all part of the recovery process.

To put it simply, while open source software has come a long way, recognising and addressing its challenges is crucial for its continued growth and success. By developing structured support models, improving licence education, emphasising user-centred design, promoting accessibility, and fostering business ecosystems, the open source community can mitigate these challenges with greater impact.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here